Robbie Evans One of our own - Page 9 - RedPassion.co.uk

southcoastexpress · 1st May 2017, 08.16:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by moynkeepthefaith

I agree , we have to evaluate Robbie on his football ability and ,for me, that is limited. Nobody disputes his attitude or his genuine affection for the club and us but he is simply not good enough and has not been for a long time. Mills showed his ineptitude as a manager by making him club captain when it is clearly not for him - he is far too quiet and cannot command the respect of his peers - leastways not when it comes to ability. I believe Mills decision was a cynical ploy to win over the supporters rather than something that was good either for the club or the lad involved.

I genuinely wish him all the best but its time to go and has been for two seasons.

Wasn't it Keates who made him captain?

Do your comments still apply?

Junior Shabadoo · 1st May 2017, 08.24:02

I feel for Robbie a bit. He is part of a long line of young players coming into bad teams, latterly the Mills circus, he has carried an injury and the idea that he never showed any improvement in three years is unfair as he showed last season that there is value in him as a box to box player. However he has played over 100 times now and has had more opportunity than most youth products lately to make a compelling case, and he hasn't done it. It's time to let someone else have a go, and as long as Barry goes with him then we can be sure that there's a serious attempt at an upgrade going on.
Posted via mobile theme

Gaz Wxm · 1st May 2017, 08.59:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by moynkeepthefaith

Mills showed his ineptitude as a manager by making him club captain when it is clearly not for him - he is far too quiet and cannot command the respect of his peers - leastways not when it comes to ability. I believe Mills decision was a cynical ploy to win over the supporters rather than something that was good either for the club or the lad involved.

lets not let the truth get in the way of on orange one bashing story .... newton was captain under mills DK put Robbie forward.... some players shine under pressure unfortunately it was too much for Robbie

pagl · 1st May 2017, 09.46:05

The problem with Evans is that he has learned absolutely nothing even after playing with Keates, Harris, Fowler and the others.

He cannot base his game simply on chasing shadows around the pitch and trying to close down. Even at this level he has a poor touch, not much vision and very rarely gets involved in some decent passing moves. He tries 100mph football with very little thought.

His commitment and passion on the field and off for the club cannot be doubted but football is about ability and sadly this is lacking.

moynkeepthefaith · 1st May 2017, 10.31:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gaz Wxm

lets not let the truth get in the way of on orange one bashing story .... newton was captain under mills DK put Robbie forward.... some players shine under pressure unfortunately it was too much for Robbie

oops - I'm old and I smell of wee. Doesn't change my opinion that Mills is a crap manager and Robbie is nether a captain nor a midfielder at this level.

Lets Av A Riot · 1st May 2017, 10.34:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by harrypothead

does anyone else think we should offer him a 6 month deal to prove his fitness or do you think the time has come for him to move on?

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

no

we cant afford to be sentimental.. no disrespect to robbie at all.. but he simply hasnt been good enough this season. and should be released.

John Neals Dynasty · 1st May 2017, 10.39:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by southcoastexpress

Wasn't it Keates who made him captain?

Do your comments still apply?

Yes Keates made him Captain Newton was captain under Mills.

But the obsession with Mills being to blame for everything is giving Dean a free ride at the moment.
Posted via mobile theme

Hometown Unicorn · 1st May 2017, 11.29:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Neals Dynasty

Yes Keates made him Captain Newton was captain under Mills.

But the obsession with Mills being to blame for everything is giving Dean a free ride at the moment.
Posted via mobile theme

Agreed. Let's hang Keates for steering us clear of the drop and saving money ahead of next season.

NedStarksGhost · 1st May 2017, 12.20:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Neals Dynasty

Yes Keates made him Captain Newton was captain under Mills.

But the obsession with Mills being to blame for everything is giving Dean a free ride at the moment.
Posted via mobile theme

Aye, that Keates has done awful.

1st May 2017, 08.24:02	#74-0 (permalink)
Junior Shabadoo Cult Hero Joined: Aug 2016 Racecourse Spot: none given Real Name: none given Twitter: @	Re: Robbie Evans One of our own I feel for Robbie a bit. He is part of a long line of young players coming into bad teams, latterly the Mills circus, he has carried an injury and the idea that he never showed any improvement in three years is unfair as he showed last season that there is value in him as a box to box player. However he has played over 100 times now and has had more opportunity than most youth products lately to make a compelling case, and he hasn't done it. It's time to let someone else have a go, and as long as Barry goes with him then we can be sure that there's a serious attempt at an upgrade going on. Posted via mobile theme

1st May 2017, 09.46:05	#76-0 (permalink)
pagl Tipped As Manager (info 1 & 2) (info) Joined: Sep 2008 Racecourse Spot: Techend Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Robbie Evans One of our own The problem with Evans is that he has learned absolutely nothing even after playing with Keates, Harris, Fowler and the others. He cannot base his game simply on chasing shadows around the pitch and trying to close down. Even at this level he has a poor touch, not much vision and very rarely gets involved in some decent passing moves. He tries 100mph football with very little thought. His commitment and passion on the field and off for the club cannot be doubted but football is about ability and sadly this is lacking.