Aldershot away ratings - RedPassion.co.uk

benwilliams · 25th November 2017, 17.22:47

Just back home, not a lot to be positive about based on that other than keeping the score down but hopefully just a one off. Aldershot were a very strong passing team with dangerous strikers who could finish, they will be there or thereabouts come the end of the season.

In terms of ratings and trying not to be too harsh:

Dunn 6 - no chance with the goals, otherwise ok
Roberts 6 - most of the attacks from them were down our left, he did ok
Smith/Pearson 6 - not as imperious as normal, their pace and movement caused them problems. Would need to see the goals back to see if anyone individually at fault
Carrington 4 - not a Carra bash as he is playing out of position but they targeted him as a weak link and ruthlessly exposed him
Rutherford 5 - largely anonymous
Wright 4 - unusually poor game, gave away possession cheaply and lost the physical battle
Wedgbury 5 - see Wright but marginally better
Kelly 5 -quiet game and lost physical side
Reid 2 - shocking miss one on one with keeper, complete fairy, good riddance
Holroyd 5 - huffed and puffed but never looked like scoring or creating

Subs - game was realistically over when Massanka and Mackreth came on, they added little - 5
Posted via mobile theme

pagl · 25th November 2017, 17.26:14

Hmm Ben. Sorry state of affairs really and sounds like we were ruthlessly exposed.
Its a worry DK played Reid again after his last 2 performances. Doesnt seem interested.

TaidTom · 25th November 2017, 17.27:05

This is pretty much how it sounded on the radio. Wright and Wedgbury didn't seem to cope with the Shots' pressing game.

TaidTom · 25th November 2017, 17.29:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by pagl

Hmm Ben. Sorry state of affairs really and sounds like we were ruthlessly exposed.

It happens to all sides during the course of a season, pagl. Hopefully we'll bounce back next week and shoot back to the top of the table.

pagl · 25th November 2017, 17.33:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by TaidTom

It happens to all sides during the course of a season, pagl. Hopefully we'll bounce back next week and shoot back to the top of the table.

IMO it shows we are an almost side with a few changes needed.

GoJohnnyGoGoGoGo · 25th November 2017, 17.34:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by pagl

Its a worry DK played Reid again after his last 2 performances.

Possibly a contractual obligation. Anyway, he's gone now.

totesey2 · 25th November 2017, 17.38:58

Wake up call for the team, More tough games to come, Not the end of the world yet!

John Neals Dynasty · 25th November 2017, 17.38:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by benwilliams

Just back home, not a lot to be positive about based on that other than keeping the score down but hopefully just a one off. Aldershot were a very strong passing team with dangerous strikers who could finish, they will be there or thereabouts come the end of the season.

In terms of ratings and trying not to be too harsh:

Dunn 6 - no chance with the goals, otherwise ok
Roberts 6 - most of the attacks from them were down our left, he did ok
Smith/Pearson 6 - not as imperious as normal, their pace and movement caused them problems. Would need to see the goals back to see if anyone individually at fault
Carrington 4 - not a Carra bash as he is playing out of position but they targeted him as a weak link and ruthlessly exposed him
Rutherford 5 - largely anonymous
Wright 4 - unusually poor game, gave away possession cheaply and lost the physical battle
Wedgbury 5 - see Wright but marginally better
Kelly 5 -quiet game and lost physical side
Reid 2 - shocking miss one on one with keeper, complete fairy, good riddance
Holroyd 5 - huffed and puffed but never looked like scoring or creating

Subs - game was realistically over when Massanka and Mackreth came on, they added little - 5
Posted via mobile theme

Refer you to the thread I posted on pace at the back and through the side which is what the Aldershot commentators said we couldn't handle their pace in defence and that our side seems to lack any on that display, it's been noticeable all season that's why we hoof it on the counter attack
Posted via mobile theme

shinton fox · 25th November 2017, 17.41:45

We were outplayed and outclassed today . Aldershot wanted to win it more than us . They were hungrier and looked fitter . They won most of the 50/50 balls and were first to the majority of second balls .

Carragher was no worse or better than any of the other players .In actual fact he constantly showed for the ball when a couple of others went missing and weren't up for the fight .

The Scott Boden situation is bizarre . Reid's loan supposedly finishes today and he looks short of confidence . This showed again today when he was one on one with their keeper and completely panicked . It was a shocking miss .

I thought Boden would start . At half time I am thinking that he has got to come on as we are 2 down and urgently need goals ! He eventually came on in injury time !

Boden was supposedly our number one signing and I would guess he is out top earner . He must be completely demotivated following today's game . If he didn't get a chance today he never will and it's pointless keeping him if DK is not going to use him .

25th November 2017, 17.22:47	#1-0 (permalink)
benwilliams Taking coaching badges Joined: Oct 2004 Racecourse Spot: MRS Real Name: Twitter: @	Aldershot away ratings Just back home, not a lot to be positive about based on that other than keeping the score down but hopefully just a one off. Aldershot were a very strong passing team with dangerous strikers who could finish, they will be there or thereabouts come the end of the season. In terms of ratings and trying not to be too harsh: Dunn 6 - no chance with the goals, otherwise ok Roberts 6 - most of the attacks from them were down our left, he did ok Smith/Pearson 6 - not as imperious as normal, their pace and movement caused them problems. Would need to see the goals back to see if anyone individually at fault Carrington 4 - not a Carra bash as he is playing out of position but they targeted him as a weak link and ruthlessly exposed him Rutherford 5 - largely anonymous Wright 4 - unusually poor game, gave away possession cheaply and lost the physical battle Wedgbury 5 - see Wright but marginally better Kelly 5 -quiet game and lost physical side Reid 2 - shocking miss one on one with keeper, complete fairy, good riddance Holroyd 5 - huffed and puffed but never looked like scoring or creating Subs - game was realistically over when Massanka and Mackreth came on, they added little - 5 Posted via mobile theme

25th November 2017, 17.26:14	#2-0 (permalink)
pagl Tipped As Manager (info 1 & 2) (info) Joined: Sep 2008 Racecourse Spot: Techend Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Aldershot away ratings Hmm Ben. Sorry state of affairs really and sounds like we were ruthlessly exposed. Its a worry DK played Reid again after his last 2 performances. Doesnt seem interested. Last edited by pagl; 25th November 2017 at 17.32:09..

25th November 2017, 17.27:05	#3-0 (permalink)
TaidTom Legend Joined: Oct 2004 Racecourse Spot: Moan Rd Stand Real Name: John Rowlands Twitter: @	Re: Aldershot away ratings This is pretty much how it sounded on the radio. Wright and Wedgbury didn't seem to cope with the Shots' pressing game.

25th November 2017, 17.38:58	#7-0 (permalink)
totesey2 Cult Hero Joined: Sep 2006 Racecourse Spot: Mold Road season ticket holder Real Name: Tom Twitter: @	Re: Aldershot away ratings Wake up call for the team, More tough games to come, Not the end of the world yet!

25th November 2017, 17.41:45	#9-0 (permalink)
shinton fox Squad Player Joined: Aug 2010 Racecourse Spot: Mainly go to away games Real Name: none given Twitter: @	Re: Aldershot away ratings We were outplayed and outclassed today . Aldershot wanted to win it more than us . They were hungrier and looked fitter . They won most of the 50/50 balls and were first to the majority of second balls . Carragher was no worse or better than any of the other players .In actual fact he constantly showed for the ball when a couple of others went missing and weren't up for the fight . The Scott Boden situation is bizarre . Reid's loan supposedly finishes today and he looks short of confidence . This showed again today when he was one on one with their keeper and completely panicked . It was a shocking miss . I thought Boden would start . At half time I am thinking that he has got to come on as we are 2 down and urgently need goals ! He eventually came on in injury time ! Boden was supposedly our number one signing and I would guess he is out top earner . He must be completely demotivated following today's game . If he didn't get a chance today he never will and it's pointless keeping him if DK is not going to use him .