Other Clubs Retained Lists - 2019 - Page 23 - RedPassion.co.uk

krux · 15th May 2019, 18.03:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Neals Dynasty

The thing is these teams at out level and league 2 release players because they ain't good enough, unlike us we offer their one's not good enough new contracts.
Posted via mobile theme

Surely players released from league 2 teams might be good enough for us?
Posted via mobile theme

John Neals Dynasty · 15th May 2019, 18.49:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by krux

Surely players released from league 2 teams might be good enough for us?
Posted via mobile theme

Well we all know the standard in league 2 is only slightly better than the top half of the National league so imho if not good enough in league 2 they are not going to improve us, prefer players released from league one and above.
Posted via mobile theme

ColwynBayGaz · 15th May 2019, 20.10:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Neals Dynasty

Well we all know the standard in league 2 is only slightly better than the top half of the National league so imho if not good enough in league 2 they are not going to improve us, prefer players released from league one and above.
Posted via mobile theme

Wouldnt you then think 'hmm why is a league 1 player willing to drop out of the football league? obviously not good enough/injury prone/no drive/ambition' ? If you go with the '1 league above isnt good enough' then cant you say the same about 1 league up? There must be dozens of players signed on to Footbal League teams who have come from lower leagues and vice versa...

Willywill · 16th May 2019, 09.26:40

I take it that any player delivering the the goods, will not be on a retained list. Being a good football manager is all about taking promising or mediocre players and coaching them into good ones. Danny Rowe and Messi are not on such lists - I wonder why? Bobby Shinton’s career at Cambridge Utd was on the rocks until we took him on and made him one of the most effective players we ever had. Beno likewise.
A great time for a manager and his coaches to select THEIR players and bond them into a functioning successful team. Can Yozzer do it?

John Neals Dynasty · 16th May 2019, 10.05:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColwynBayGaz

Wouldnt you then think 'hmm why is a league 1 player willing to drop out of the football league? obviously not good enough/injury prone/no drive/ambition' ? If you go with the '1 league above isnt good enough' then cant you say the same about 1 league up? There must be dozens of players signed on to Footbal League teams who have come from lower leagues and vice versa...

Well league one do have more skill and I prefer players with experience to kids at this level, so I'm talking players early to Mid 30s, players who have been there and done it, not kids of 22 like Wright being called raw instead of s***e but hey its down to opinions if you want national north signings like Ainge then be prepared to keep our non ambitious position of National league wannabes.
Posted via mobile theme

ColwynBayGaz · 16th May 2019, 11.39:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Neals Dynasty

Well league one do have more skill and I prefer players with experience to kids at this level, so I'm talking players early to Mid 30s, players who have been there and done it, not kids of 22 like Wright being called raw instead of s***e but hey its down to opinions if you want national north signings like Ainge then be prepared to keep our non ambitious position of National league wannabes.
Posted via mobile theme

Oddly I dont remember me mentioning Ainge...Bobby Grant was a league one player, if you want to base an argument on one signing then that must mean you think he's good? I seem to remember a certain striker playing for Stocksbridge Park Steels in the 8th tier of football signing for Fleetwood, but hey, judging by what you say, any signings from the leagues below must be crap?

benwilliams · 16th May 2019, 11.43:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColwynBayGaz

Oddly I dont remember me mentioning Ainge...Bobby Grant was a league one player, if you want to base an argument on one signing then that must mean you think he's good? I seem to remember a certain striker playing for Stocksbridge Park Steels in the 8th tier of football signing for Fleetwood, but hey, judging by what you say, any signings from the leagues below must be crap?

Think Vardy went there via Halifax but your point still holds!

pagl · 16th May 2019, 11.52:51

Wasn’t Keates and the end of his league career and a steal by Saunders.
A find like that would be great. Leader and still with ability and could run the midfield.

jackoboy17 · 16th May 2019, 12.17:38

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/48296137

Port vale

16th May 2019, 09.26:40	#202-0 (permalink)
Willywill Due a Testimonial Joined: Oct 2004 Racecourse Spot: Yale stand Real Name: Johnny Windows Twitter: @	Re: Other Clubs Retained Lists - 2019 I take it that any player delivering the the goods, will not be on a retained list. Being a good football manager is all about taking promising or mediocre players and coaching them into good ones. Danny Rowe and Messi are not on such lists - I wonder why? Bobby Shinton’s career at Cambridge Utd was on the rocks until we took him on and made him one of the most effective players we ever had. Beno likewise. A great time for a manager and his coaches to select THEIR players and bond them into a functioning successful team. Can Yozzer do it?

16th May 2019, 11.52:51	#206-0 (permalink)
pagl Tipped As Manager (info 1 & 2) (info) Joined: Sep 2008 Racecourse Spot: Techend Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Other Clubs Retained Lists - 2019 Wasn’t Keates and the end of his league career and a steal by Saunders. A find like that would be great. Leader and still with ability and could run the midfield.

16th May 2019, 12.17:38	#207-0 (permalink)
jackoboy17 First Teamer Joined: May 2016 Racecourse Spot: none given Real Name: rw Twitter: @	Re: Other Clubs Retained Lists - 2019 https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/48296137 Port vale