Referee Rating - RedPassion.co.uk

Red_Jackoisback · 20th October 2018, 18.14:40

I am completely fed up with the poorer than poor standard of refereeing this standard. The guy today was an absolute joke. A caution for Mike before half time - never. Then their player did the same just after the break and nothing. I just don’t get it.

IMO the standard of referees is spoiling the game

Hawarden Red10 · 20th October 2018, 20.37:14

Must say we've had some shockers this season but equally I think we've had some very good ones, more than usual. Certainly seem to get Jekyll or Hyde at the moment.

Alan Attack · 20th October 2018, 20.43:34

I suggest the standard is on par with the standard of players.

fluffysheepsupporter · 20th October 2018, 21.30:17

Does the same referree get the replay? Hope not . He certainly got an earfull from the Wrexham bench at the end of the match.

jonesfach · 20th October 2018, 21.43:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by fluffysheepsupporter

Does the same referree get the replay? Hope not . He certainly got an earfull from the Wrexham bench at the end of the match.

It used to be the case don't know whether it still is.

Lods · 20th October 2018, 21.48:13

+It's unfortunately the standard at the level. You either get referees who have peaked at this level for years and years (usually for good reason) or up-and-coming refs lacking experience. The former are usually the curmudgeons who don't let the game flow and blow their whistle every time players get withing a yard of each other, and the latter are usually the ones who miss key decisions or get them wrong.

It's frustrating, but we're hardly the only team who has an issue with poor refereeing.

Alan Attack · 20th October 2018, 22.03:08

If you’ve ever tried to ref a game, please comment. I have at u14 and 16 kids level (as an 18/19 year old) and it was hard. Intimidated by everyone; players, coaches, managers and supporters. As such, I’ll seldom criticise a ref. Without them, the game goes to shit.

corwenred · 20th October 2018, 22.33:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lods

+It's unfortunately the standard at the level. You either get referees who have peaked at this level for years and years (usually for good reason) or up-and-coming refs lacking experience. The former are usually the curmudgeons who don't let the game flow and blow their whistle every time players get withing a yard of each other, and the latter are usually the ones who miss key decisions or get them wrong.

It's frustrating, but we're hardly the only team who has an issue with poor refereeing.

Think this ref was more of the latter, my biggest gripe was the amount of times he penalised Fondop for battling with their centre half, he's a bloody strong lad and he gets punished for it, the booking was a tad harsh but can see why it was given.
Also I can't for the life of me understand why the linesman waited for Fondop to lob their keeper before flagging.

Red_Jackoisback · 20th October 2018, 23.36:17

Yes I have tried being a ref and I was useless, just as I was at playing football.

I therefore understand ooor referring but just don’t get inconsistent or one sided.

Just seems worse to me today but have calmed down now.

Interesting to see how far offside Fondop was.

They were a very clever niggley team I thought.

20th October 2018, 18.14:40	#1-0 (permalink)
Red_Jackoisback Club Captain Joined: Jun 2010 Racecourse Spot: mold road stand Real Name: david jackson Twitter: @	Referee Rating I am completely fed up with the poorer than poor standard of refereeing this standard. The guy today was an absolute joke. A caution for Mike before half time - never. Then their player did the same just after the break and nothing. I just don’t get it. IMO the standard of referees is spoiling the game

20th October 2018, 20.37:14	#2-0 (permalink)
Hawarden Red10 First Teamer Joined: Aug 2011 Racecourse Spot: Paddock Real Name: none given Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating Must say we've had some shockers this season but equally I think we've had some very good ones, more than usual. Certainly seem to get Jekyll or Hyde at the moment.

20th October 2018, 20.43:34	#3-0 (permalink)
Alan Attack Printing My Own Banknotes Joined: Feb 2005 Racecourse Spot: Mold Road End Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating I suggest the standard is on par with the standard of players.

20th October 2018, 21.30:17	#4-0 (permalink)
fluffysheepsupporter Taking coaching badges Joined: Jul 2012 Racecourse Spot: UPPER YALE STAND TOWN END Real Name: GRAHAM Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating Does the same referree get the replay? Hope not . He certainly got an earfull from the Wrexham bench at the end of the match. Last edited by fluffysheepsupporter; 20th October 2018 at 21.30:52.. Reason: .

20th October 2018, 21.48:13	#6-0 (permalink)
Lods Cult Hero Joined: Dec 2017 Racecourse Spot: Wherever the new ticketing process lets me sit Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating +It's unfortunately the standard at the level. You either get referees who have peaked at this level for years and years (usually for good reason) or up-and-coming refs lacking experience. The former are usually the curmudgeons who don't let the game flow and blow their whistle every time players get withing a yard of each other, and the latter are usually the ones who miss key decisions or get them wrong. It's frustrating, but we're hardly the only team who has an issue with poor refereeing. Last edited by Lods; 20th October 2018 at 21.50:35..

20th October 2018, 22.03:08	#7-0 (permalink)
Alan Attack Printing My Own Banknotes Joined: Feb 2005 Racecourse Spot: Mold Road End Real Name: Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating If you’ve ever tried to ref a game, please comment. I have at u14 and 16 kids level (as an 18/19 year old) and it was hard. Intimidated by everyone; players, coaches, managers and supporters. As such, I’ll seldom criticise a ref. Without them, the game goes to shit.

20th October 2018, 23.36:17	#9-0 (permalink)
Red_Jackoisback Club Captain Joined: Jun 2010 Racecourse Spot: mold road stand Real Name: david jackson Twitter: @	Re: Referee Rating Yes I have tried being a ref and I was useless, just as I was at playing football. I therefore understand ooor referring but just don’t get inconsistent or one sided. Just seems worse to me today but have calmed down now. Interesting to see how far offside Fondop was. They were a very clever niggley team I thought.